The screen for electing the city PTE, says the following:
An authorized person may make this election on behalf of an eligible entity if the entity is opting in to the New York State PTET and:
if the entity is an S corporation, it is choosing to be taxed as a resident S corporation for PTET purposes, and all its shareholders are city resident individualsSo it seems that a NYS S corporation cannot make an election for NYC PTET if even one shareholder is a non- resident. What if all the shareholders are residents and one of the shareholders is a trust. The beneficiary of the Sub-Chapter S trust is not a NYC resident but the trustee of the trust is.
------------------------------
Gabriel Bentovim
HOFFMAN & BENTOVIM, CPAs PC
Commack NY
631-499-1500
------------------------------